The focus is back on singing and not a moment season too soon! I have been keeping on Idol this season solely through the magic of the internets which has an interesting benefit of keeping a lot of the judge's opinions out of my head.
So, based only on my impressions of their singing performances, I present my Top 9 for this season (short commentary on each below):
I will title this season as the Season of Individuals... there are truly some unique and distinct voices and I am so glad that America gets to hear them.
SCOTTY MCCREERY - A favorite for me since he opened his mouth at his first audition. Not only does Idol need a male country winner to round out it's stable of champions but I personally like that he is representing those of us that don't sing tenor!
LAUREN ALAINA - Another favorite of mine from the get-go, she's a little bit Kelly and a little bit Carrie... she's one of the only youngins that I worry about nerves. She also has a little backlash going because she has been so heavily praised up to this point.
STEFANO LANGONE - He's undeniably happy and cute but he didn't win me over until his Wild Card performance of "I Need You Now". Now I know he has depth and he knows he has another fan.
THIA MEGIA - Another one that I wasn't convinced of... sure she's got the voice but little girls who try to hard to sing like women (i.e. Charice) always bug me. But I've realized that she isn't trying to sing like an adult, it's that way naturally. She's poised, confident and I would be scared of her if I was a girl in Top 13.
PAUL MCDONALD - I don't think America is ready to crown someone like Paul as The American Idol but I am so glad he made it this far! Pllllleeeeease give him a chance to sing some Ray LaMontagne!
ASHTON JONES - I need a black diva in my life (and in this competition) but let's hope she can break the curse and make it farther than the other greats like J.Hud, Trenyce, etc.
CASEY ABRAMS - Another super unique singer that I doubt America is ready to see go all the way. He's one of those that surprises me with his song choice and arrangements. I can't wait to see what he does next!
JACOB LUSK - OK, maybe I need TWO black divas in my life. His control and range are INSANE.
PIA TOSCANO - First it's fun to say her name. Second she is crazy good. If she can make an up-tempo song sound as good as a ballad she may be unstoppable.